The Santa Monica City Council voted this week to order an independent review of the Santa Monica Police Department response to the Sunday, May 31st, Santa Monica Protest and resulting looting of hundreds of businesses.
The vote for an independent investigation was in part a response to 60,000 people as of Tuesday, June 9th signing a petition to fire Santa Monica Police Chief Cynthia Renaud over SMPD handling of the May 31st Protest and looting. As of this posting 62,000 people have signed the petition.
Chief Renaud a Long Beach native and graduate of CSULB, has been under fire for not only the widespread looting, but also Santa Monica’s use of rubber bullets and tear gas on protestors who were blocks away from the areas of downtown Santa Monica getting looted.
The Santa Monica City Council also called for the investigation to include the days leading up to May 31st. Santa Monica Councilwomen Sue Himmelrich who proposed the investigation noted that the Santa Monica Police Department would be conducting its own investigation but said at the Tuesday Santa Monica Council meeting that she believed the May 31st incident should also be investigated independently. Himmelrich suggested the OIR Group. a well-known police overview and review company. Himmelrich also proposed the money for the independent investigation would be from the SMPD budget.
SMPD Chief Renaud released a statement welcoming the independent review before the City Council vote:
“As Police Chief, I welcome a thorough, independent review of the events of May 31, building on the after-action review I have committed to conducting within the Department,”
According to the Santa Monica Mirror, residents were also concerned about the Press Conference the following day and what many consider a victory lap minimizing the damage by focusing on no major injuries or loss of life.
The similarities of the Santa Monica’s protest and the Long Beach Protest go beyond being on the same day Sunday, May 31st. The protest in Santa Monica started at 1 pm. just two hours before the Long Beach 3 pm protest In both cities, the looting started blocks away from the main peaceful protest group. Both cities held a press conference immediately the next day where city officials and the police administrators focused on the message that no deaths or injuries occurred despite the widespread losses to businesses.
The similarities stop there.
When the looting started in Santa Monica, city officials quickly called for a 4 pm curfew. Soon after, Los Angeles County and City called for a 6 pm curfew- both curfews were well before dark. Long Beach was the last to call a curfew with Mayor Garcia calling the curfew for a past-sundown 9 pm curfew, even after the looting had spread from The Pike Outlets to Pine Ave and then north and east across the city.
Santa Monica was quickly able to get the National Guard into the city, with L.A.Television stations reporting the National Guard arriving in Santa Monica just four hours after the protest started. At Tuesday’s Long Beach City Council meeting LBPD Chief Robert Luna said the National Guard arrived in Long Beach at 12 midnight. Long Beach City Manager Tom Modica at the Tuesday night City Council Meeting reported that the city was asked if it wanted the National Guard at about 8:40 pm when no mutual aid was available.
Santa Monica Police arrested over 400 people on that Sunday. LBPD Chief Luna announced Tuesday that the arrest count for Long Beach’s civil unrest is now at 98 with 71 misdemeanor citations (tickets). Luna emphasized that those citations were still arrests even if the persons cited were not held. Under pressure for a timeline or deadline from Second District Councilwomen Jeannie Pearce, Chief Luna would not commit to when a report on the break down of the 98 arrests would be made available.
In an interview with Los Angeles Magazine, SMPD executive officer Joseph Cortez was questioned about the looting. Pressed about looting in front of officers, Cortez stated:
“But the Santa Monica Police Department places a higher priority on life and public safety. When the radio traffic is, “We have a person with a gun”— and there were a couple of these—we arrest the people with the guns. We arrested violent people. And so, the decision was to start dealing with the public safety aspect of it first until we got more reinforcements, then we could handle the looting. But we have to do an after-action review and find out if our tactics were lacking in any way.”
After viewing footage of looters swarming stores unchecked for hours, one former top-ranking police official became convinced that officers were told not to make arrests.
“It kind of speaks for itself,” the former official said. “The officers looked the other way.
“Squad cars drove by the looters and didn’t stop. They were within 25 yards of people committing crimes.
“If you had arrested just three people,” he said, “everybody would stand down. You do it from the beginning.”
Also during the June 9th Santa Monica City Council Meeting, the City Council voted to explore relocating police funding in next year’s budget to crime prevention and youth programs. The Santa Monica Daily Press reported:
“The council voted to explore various police reforms, open an independent review of SMPD’s response to the May 31 unrest and create a Black Agenda to address systemic racism in Santa Monica.
Council members asked city staff to present a plan on June 29 to reallocate some money from the police department’s budget, which would comprise 30% of the city’s $348.2 million discretionary budget next fiscal year, to fund crime prevention efforts, including youth programs. “